Symphytum
may be considered the orthopædic specific of herbal medicine. "The
roots of Comfrey stamped, and the juice drunk with wine, helpeth those
that spit blood and healeth all inward wounds and burstings. The same
bruised and laid to in manner of a plaister, doth heal all fresh and
green wounds, and are so glutinative, that it will solder and glue
together meat that is chopped in pieces, seething in a pot, and make it
in one lump" (Gerarde). Peter Squire (Squire's
Companion to B. P., 6th ed.) gives as the "medicinal
properties" of Symph.:
"Astringent, mucilaginous, glutinous; useful to form cases for
injured limbs. The black rind (of root) is scraped off and the
mucilaginous root is then scraped carefully into a nice even pulp; this
spread of the thickness of a crown-piece upon cambric or old muslin is
wrapped round the limb and bandaged over; it shortly stiffens, and forms
a casing superior to starch, giving support and strength to the
part." P. Squire knew a bone-setter who practised fifty years ago,
and rendered himself famous for setting compound fractures with this
root, which he kept secret, and he never removed the bandage after the
first dressing until the limb was well (R. T. C). Symphytum
has not received its names for nothing. Consolida
is one of them; and "Comfrey" is derived from Confirmare.
The glutinous juice of the root seems, according to Gerarde, to have
given the key to its action as a vulnerary. H. C. Allen (Med.
Cent., quoted Ind. H. Rev.,
v. 60) refers to the following indications for Symph.
given by Lippe: (1) When the bone or
periosteum has been injured and the soft parts have recovered from the
bruised soreness under Arn., the
remaining pain and soreness of periosteum may be promptly relieved by Symp.
(2) In traumatic injuries of bone or
periosteum (as from a snowball or anything else on the face), Symp.
was the only remedy Lippe has seen efficient. He cured many cases after
others had used Arn. and failed. (3)
Here is one of his cures: "More than a year ago fell and struck
knee on a stone; wound healed and scarcely left any trace, but there
remained an acute stitching pain at point of injury, felt when the part
was touched by clothing as when knee was bent." Allen also gives
the following cure reported by Fowler: Mrs. J. stepped on the edge of a
scantling, which rolled, and she turned her ankle. In a few minutes the
ankle began to swell and become painful, pain increasing rapidly, so
that in an hour or two patient was in great agony. She declared her leg
was broken, she "could feel the rough ends of the broken bones
jagging into the flesh": could not bear any one to approach her for
fear of being hurt. No discoloration whatever. Symp.
promptly relieved, so that she went about her usual duties in
forty-eight hours. Allen regards pricking
pain as a guiding symptom. Next to bone injuries in importance are
injuries to the ball of the eye, as
distinguished from injuries to the soft parts
around. "I have long since ceased to use Arn.
in injuries of the globe of the eye, Symp.
having given such prompt and permanent relief" (H. C. Allen). [I
have, however, seen Arn. speedily
clear up hæmorrhage into the vitreous from a blow of a cork from a
soda-water bottle.─J. H. C.] Allen gives these
indications: Severe pain in globe of eye after an injury by a blunt
instrument (snowball; cane; point of umbrella; infant's fist), the soft
parts remaining intact, Croserio (New, Old, and
Forgotten Remedies) was one of the first to use Symp.
in the potencies for fractures. P. P. Wells translated Croserio's Connection
of Homœopathy with Surgery, in which this passage occurs:
"Injuries of the bones are healed most promptly with Symp.
30, internally, once a day." Wells gives these cases of his own: (1)
Boy, 14, broke bone of forearm at junction of middle and lower thirds,
two years before. Had twice repeated the fracture by slight falls. Ends
now slightly movable on each other, arm of little use. Three doses of Symp.
made a perfect cure, and the boy became robust and much better in health
than he had ever been before. (2)
Boy, 8, fractured humerus near junction of condyles and shaft. Arn.
30 immediately arrested the spasmodic jerks of muscles of injured arm. Arn.
was continued three days, by which time all traumatic fever had
subsided. Symp. 3, one drop in half
a tumbler of water; a teaspoonful morning and evening. The splints were
removed the ninth day, and the bone found consolidated. The cure was
entirely without pain. F. H. Brett (H. W.,
xxv. 304) cured himself of inguinal rupture by rubbing the part with
tincture of the root. On another occasion a blow on the lower part of
the back from a fall resulted in a secondary affection of the spine in
the mid-dorsal region, a protuberance as if from a slight dislocation
appearing at the spot. Again Symp.
Ø was applied. The tenderness at the point subsided after three
applications, and in a few days the protuberance disappeared. Brett
mentions (ib., 379) a case he had
heard of: A diseased arm which had begun to mortify was dressed with a
poultice of Comfrey root, and this "drew off the mortified
substance, and the arm became sound again." Sir Wm. Thomson, of
Dublin (Lancet, Nov. 28, 1896)
relates a case of malignant tumour of the antrum which had extended to
the nose. Microscopical examination proved it to be round-celled
sarcoma. The patient, a man, was advised to have the jaw removed. This
advice was refused at the time, and was repeated by Felix Semon, who saw
the man later. After still further delay Thomson performed the operation
in the month of May, 1896. A month later the growth began to show again,
increased rapidly, closed the right eye, was blue, tense, firm,
lobulated, but did not break. Thomson declined to operate again. Early
in October the man walked into Thomson's study well: "The tumour
had completely disappeared from the face, and I could not identify any
trace of it in the mouth." The man had applied poultices of Comfrey
root, and the swelling disappeared. Cooper (H.
W., xxxii. 403) gives this experience of a patient of his:
just before her marriage she had a dangerous attack of scarlatina,
leaving abscesses on both sides of the neck and great internal swelling,
so that she could swallow only liquids, and that with great difficulty.
The external swelling extended from ear to chin, and was hard and very
painful. Poultices of Comfrey root were applied. The pain was
immediately relieved and her abscesses decreased rapidly until they were
entirely absorbed, without external opening so far as the patient could
remark. Hering (from whom I have taken the main part of my Schema) says Symp.
has had a fragmentary proving by Macfarlan. Gerarde adds to the uses of Symp.
quoted from him above that it cases pains in the back from violent
motion as wrestling, or from excessive sexual indulgence, even when
spermatorrhœa has been induced thereby. Arn.
has an analogous use. Peculiar Sensations
are: As if upper lid passed over an elevation on closing eye. As if ears
were stopped up. The symptoms are: <
By touch. Sitting = pain about
navel. Stooping = weight in
forehead. Walking = pain opposite
spleen.